Look across the evidence
Compare papers.
The same rubric, side by side. A comparison of claim support—not a contest between fields.
| Criterion | The ATLAS Higgs discovery: strong evidence, carefully bounded |
|---|---|
| Overall claim grade | A 98/100 |
| Claim examined | ATLAS observed a new neutral boson near 126 GeV whose production and decay were compatible with a Standard Model Higgs boson. |
| Claim support40% weight | 5/5 Multiple decay channels and later measurements sustain the new-boson interpretation. [1, 3, 4] |
| Methods & controls20% weight | 5/5 Combined channels, quantified backgrounds and separate statistical/systematic uncertainties support a strong discovery design. [1] |
| Independent checks20% weight | 5/5 CMS observed a compatible particle with a different detector and analysis collaboration. Shared accelerator conditions remain relevant. [2] |
| Transparency10% weight | 4/5 Papers and supporting figures document the analyses, but this review did not reproduce the full detector-to-result chain. [1, 4] |
| Claim calibration10% weight | 5/5 The original conclusion said compatible with the Standard Model Higgs, leaving detailed identity tests to later work. [1, 3] |
| Evidence status | Independently corroborated |